IRC log for #sporewiki on 20160705

00:03.32*** join/#sporewiki DrodoEmpire (2f37c5db@gateway/web/freenode/ip.47.55.197.219)
00:09.40DrodoEmpiretest
00:09.51DrodoEmpiretest
00:10.35*** join/#sporewiki Wormy_ (02184654@gateway/web/freenode/ip.2.24.70.84)
00:10.44Wormy_hi
00:10.56DrodoEmpireHi
00:11.53The_Randomnesswb
00:13.36Wormy_I wonder if true AGI (strong AI, aka people) will be in a sense freer than human beings when it comes to their place in society.  There is much spoken about how automation could replace most if not all jobs.  For narrow AI, I dispute they could take all jobs (surely not creative or intellectual ones), though AGI could.  However, to use AGI like we use narrow AI today would be slavery
00:14.39Wormy_AGI people would work by choice.  But why would they work in the human world, if they were digital or something like that, they are already outside most of the human sphere (the need for housing, eating etc.).  How would they be paid?  With more power, more computing resources?
00:15.09Wormy_Or would AGI just do their own thing free of most other human soceital limitations
00:15.13*** join/#sporewiki DrodoEmpire_ (2f37c5db@gateway/web/freenode/ip.47.55.197.219)
00:15.26DrodoEmpire_Other computer's frozen and having internet issues
00:15.27DrodoEmpire_>.<
00:17.06Wormy_Anyway that was my "On the toilet" thoughts
00:17.41The_RandomnessWormy_: They would sit around and produce spicy AGI memes
00:17.54Wormy_Sounds like my kind of life
00:18.12The_RandomnessAnd laugh with us at the singularitarians
00:18.19Wormy_Indeed
00:18.27DrodoEmpire_Aw, I missed Wormy's toilet thoughts >:
00:18.45Wormy_http://pastie.org/private/fnlw6cix5xnfdlbemnq
00:20.15DrodoEmpire_Tough question
00:20.46DrodoEmpire_I presume a sapient AI with human intellegence would also have societal expectations like humans, at least once they become accepted members of society
00:21.21DrodoEmpire_If they also existed in an android unit, even moreso
00:21.38Wormy_yeah
00:22.18DrodoEmpire_So I mean... I figure at that point they'd be paid like any other human and work like one (albeit in an occupation befitting their processing power, like a hyperadministrator or something)
00:22.57DrodoEmpire_They *may* end up with certain inequalities though, I dunno- maybe they'd be exempt from military draft? I dunno
00:23.02DrodoEmpire_That's just an example
00:23.35Wormy_Seems to depend on how accepted they could be
00:24.21DrodoEmpire_All I know is that fictionwise Drodo distrust androids and robots, and have any production of them regulated out of possibility
00:24.40DrodoEmpire_(One of the few things the government regulates heavily, and only because most Drodo cultures can agree on it >.<)
00:25.09DrodoEmpire_Foreign androids are probably seen with a bit of suspicion too, but it'd depend
00:26.52DrodoEmpire_If they're particularly convincing, your average Drodo might not even notice :p
00:26.53Wormy_Not sure how AI fit in DCP society.  They probably have to conform to the DCP's power structure (so no over-aching Kurzweilian Skynet)
00:27.00DrodoEmpire_Ahh
00:27.09Wormy_But discrimination within the DCP of course is punishable
00:27.33DrodoEmpire_Drodo - That French guy is even paler than usual...
00:27.53DrodoEmpire_Drodo - ...Aand he's a know-it-all. That's French for sure <.<
00:27.54MonetI've mentioned androids with rights comparable to organics in the DI
00:32.16MonetThough I suppose with the Draconis the line between synthetic and organic starts to blur
00:38.15DrodoEmpire_Yeah
00:38.30DrodoEmpire_And really I sorta figure that's what might happen with advanced societies
01:10.43The_RandomnessYeah, makes sense
01:25.07*** join/#sporewiki The_Randomness (~chatzilla@2601:441:1:5b80:4961:d2a8:cb3e:37d0)
01:25.08*** mode/#sporewiki [+o The_Randomness] by ChanServ
01:25.25The_Randomnesshm, that was strange
01:42.40Wormy_gimme dat fish nao http://www.storyofsize.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/Elephant-Seal-01-634x443.jpg
01:46.32DrodoEmpire_ayy lmao
01:47.10Wormy_DrodoEmpire_ Didn't you want to know more about Jeremy Kyle Show?  This is all you need to know https://twitter.com/savs66/status/750037114402865152
01:48.29DrodoEmpire_Oh dear
01:53.50The_RandomnessWutFace
01:53.57Wormy_more watface https://twitter.com/edgarwright/status/749550743435223040
01:54.31*** join/#sporewiki Tek0516 (uid149600@gateway/web/irccloud.com/x-vwxahmpcfjtmmzju)
01:54.45The_Randomnesswat
01:59.34DrodoEmpire_wot
02:00.10DrodoEmpire_British tabloids are so much fun
02:01.03DrodoEmpire_http://spore.wikia.com/wiki/One:wone - I don't even know
02:01.38Wormy_Our TV news is a bit dry...  Unlike American news it seems
02:02.27DrodoEmpire_British tabloids seem like they're harmless fun- American media sensationalises terrorists and in that regard they're harmful I think
02:02.46DrodoEmpire_Correct me if I'm wrong though
02:03.08MonetBritish Tabloids do that second bit.
02:03.30Wormy_Is that article trying to emulate the mind of Jaden Smith?
02:04.45DrodoEmpire_olol
02:04.58MonetThough if British Tabloids look like 'harmless fun' from an American/Canadian perspective. That must mean American tablod journalism is completely off-the-wall to us.
02:05.06Wormy_http://spore.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:213829
02:05.16Wormy_Actually I like this user
02:06.00DrodoEmpire_Monet: Its mostly about celebrities and stuff- probably more of the same but we don't really give it much attention
02:06.21DrodoEmpire_Yeah he might turn out fine
02:06.30DrodoEmpire_Just seems like a bit of an oddball
02:10.17DrodoEmpire_https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHLs8dDkFls - This has got to be my one of my favourite clutches in CS:GO
02:10.18Monetgoodnight
02:10.21DrodoEmpire_Night
02:13.30Wormy_I should go as well, night
04:32.24drom~infobot test
04:32.24infobotsomebody said test was not funny
04:32.28dromwhew
05:50.25*** join/#sporewiki drom_ (~drom@unaffiliated/drom)
06:49.24*** join/#sporewiki Liquid_Ink (79d0cd9d@gateway/web/freenode/ip.121.208.205.157)
07:10.11*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid2 (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
07:57.40*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
08:30.41*** join/#sporewiki Ghelae (6d9ec918@gateway/web/freenode/ip.109.158.201.24)
08:30.41*** mode/#sporewiki [+o Ghelae] by ChanServ
09:37.59*** join/#sporewiki Charles_Murray (53713253@gateway/web/freenode/ip.83.113.50.83)
10:49.09*** join/#sporewiki Charles_PC (53713253@gateway/web/freenode/ip.83.113.50.83)
10:56.55*** join/#sporewiki Monet (~Monet47@cpc90522-gill20-2-0-cust960.20-1.cable.virginm.net)
11:26.16*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
11:45.20*** join/#sporewiki Hachiman (5aff252c@gateway/web/freenode/ip.90.255.37.44)
11:45.28HachimanHi
11:46.54MonetHi
11:53.36GhelaeHi
12:05.39*** join/#sporewiki Wormy_ (02184654@gateway/web/freenode/ip.2.24.70.84)
12:07.00HachimanWormy_: Juno is now in Jupiter's orbit
12:07.50Wormy_I saw
12:07.56Wormy_Great stuff
12:09.47*** join/#sporewiki Jepardi (591b4d42@gateway/web/freenode/ip.89.27.77.66)
12:09.49JepardiHi
12:19.39*** join/#sporewiki Tek0516 (uid149600@gateway/web/irccloud.com/x-yvuzofghxptfjrwp)
12:30.28Wormy_https://twitter.com/seanmcarroll/status/749473190464806912
12:32.24HachimanOh wow
12:32.41*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
12:41.18*** join/#sporewiki Charles_PC (53713253@gateway/web/freenode/ip.83.113.50.83)
12:43.01Tek0516Hello
13:05.50*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid2 (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
13:35.13*** join/#sporewiki DrodoEmpire (2f37c5db@gateway/web/freenode/ip.47.55.197.219)
13:35.24DrodoEmpireHi everyone
13:52.23MonetHello
14:00.11*** join/#sporewiki DrodoEmpire (2f37c5db@gateway/web/freenode/ip.47.55.197.219)
14:19.59ImpyDroid2Hachiman: So the Death Note film cast has been announced and everyone is whining about L being played by a black guy
14:20.13HachimanWhat the fuck
14:20.14ImpyDroid2That everyone else is played by white actors is apparently okay
14:20.27HachimanWhat the
14:20.33HachimanAre they Americanizing Death Note
14:21.23HachimanThere are already two popular Death Note live action films
14:22.38ImpyDroid2Well obviously an American studio would americanise it
14:23.07MonetDon't Japanese studios do similar when they adapt Western franchises?
14:24.15DrodoEmpireHistorically that's what happens really- the characters are changed to the local ethnicites, be they fictional or religious and or whatever else
14:24.15MonetOr is it Chinese?
14:24.22HachimanChinese
14:24.46DrodoEmpireI mean, Jesus is/was depicted as asian by Chinese Christians, white by European Christians, etc.
14:24.59DrodoEmpireDespite the fact he was likely semitic/Syrian
14:25.06ImpyDroid2Monet: Well obviously race lifting is a thing but why complai about the black L in particular
14:25.17ImpyDroid2When EVERYONE is being racebent
14:25.47DrodoEmpireI dunno, if you're going to arbitrarily change the race of some character it doesn't really matter to what race they're changed- you've already done it >.<
14:26.14HachimanBecause there's some form of homo subtext going on between Light and L and people probably cannot stand the idea of a fully-grown black man having this kind of relationship with a white school student
14:29.33ImpyDroid2Hachiman: Light dropped the soap
14:30.22HachimanAlso, the Japanese tend to draw their anime / manga characters as if they were white rather than actually Japanese, so casting white people to play those characters makes some sense
14:30.45ImpyDroid2Well the actual term is "raceless" I think
14:31.39ImpyDroid2Oh come on you are actually saying race lift to white is okay but to black isn't
14:31.39ImpyDroid2Seriously?
14:31.49HachimanWhat the fuck, I didn't say that
14:32.38ImpyDroid2You just did
14:32.54MonetI've heard complates over Motoko Kurosagi being played by Scarlett Johanssen
14:33.41HachimanI'm not complaining about a black L; I'm making assumptions as to WHY people could be upset over a black L
14:34.02MonetMy stance on it is the Major's 90% robot so why should her skin colour matter?
14:34.06HachimanStop putting fucking words in my mouth you imbecile
14:34.28ImpyDroid2Who are you calling an imbecile
14:34.28DrodoEmpireYeah, Impy, you did put words in his mouth
14:34.32ImpyDroid2Calm down
14:34.34DrodoEmpireBoth of you shut up
14:34.46Hachiman>Calm down
14:35.00HachimanYou're the one who accused me of supporting white supremacy
14:35.08DrodoEmpireHachi, please? If you two want to argue take it to PMs
14:35.17ImpyDroid2Did I insult you though
14:35.17DrodoEmpireOtherwise, stop this right now
14:35.25HachimanI felt offended
14:36.00ImpyDroid2You could explain yourself then
14:36.04HachimanI just did
14:36.07HachimanCan you not read
14:36.12ImpyDroid2And you called me an imbecile
14:36.17ImpyDroid2Nobody insults me
14:36.41ImpyDroid2You explained yourself sure
14:36.48HachimanThey do if you're going to act paranoid and accuse people of racism at first opportunity
14:37.27ImpyDroid2Well pardon me for drawing conclusions but I was not the one who descended into insults to
15:00.03ImpyDroid2I.
15:32.47*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
15:54.17*** join/#sporewiki DrodoEmpire_ (2f37c5db@gateway/web/freenode/ip.47.55.197.219)
16:30.25*** join/#sporewiki Cyrannian (uid97882@gateway/web/irccloud.com/x-zvrfatcsblysicls)
16:30.25*** mode/#sporewiki [+o Cyrannian] by ChanServ
16:31.16CyrannianHi
16:32.25Technobliteratorhihi
16:33.36MonetHi
16:49.12Wormy_https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hy32A2NoCVw
16:52.50*** join/#sporewiki Treebeard (52068dfd@gateway/web/freenode/ip.82.6.141.253)
16:54.30CyrannianHi Treebeard
16:54.49TreebeardHello
16:55.10DrodoEmpire_Hi
16:55.44MonetHello
17:02.28*** join/#sporewiki AdmiralPanda (65b30e25@gateway/web/freenode/ip.101.179.14.37)
17:02.52AdmiralPandahi all
17:05.19Wormy_So someone gave death threats to Stephen Hawking http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/woman-arrested-armed-police-guard-8323284
17:42.51*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid (~Anders@89.140.67.26.static.user.ono.com)
17:44.49*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid2 (~Anders@89.140.67.26.static.user.ono.com)
17:48.21*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid (~Anders@89.140.67.26.static.user.ono.com)
18:02.35Tek0516Wormy_: http://www.smbc-comics.com/comics/1467730772-20160705.png
18:03.14Wormy_lol
18:10.57*** join/#sporewiki Tybusen (44055b82@gateway/web/freenode/ip.68.5.91.130)
18:11.49TybusenGood morning
18:14.30Tek0516Good afternoon Tybusen
18:14.30TybusenTechnobliterator: I was thinking about picking up Final Fantasy VI, which version of FFVI do you think is the best?
18:15.13TybusenTek0516: ye non-west coast hoser
18:19.54DrodoEmpire_Hi
18:21.13drom_Another day, still no 10 USBs in my mailbox
18:24.41Charles_PCtst
18:25.21TybusenYou dropped your 'e'
18:25.57DrodoEmpire_picks the e back up, dusts it off, and puts it back in Charles' coat pocket
18:26.09DrodoEmpire_Keep care're your stuff, alright?
18:30.07Wormy_Nobody wants an e
18:31.38drom_Hey. If you don't want your 'e's I can take them off you if you want.
18:35.34drom_Wormy_: https://youtu.be/JFl8k-rloyU
18:36.57Wormy_милый
18:37.03*** join/#sporewiki The_Randomness (~The_Rando@x-131-212-249-208.uofm-secure.wireless.umn.edu)
18:37.03*** mode/#sporewiki [+o The_Randomness] by ChanServ
18:37.15The_RandomnessHello
18:38.48drom_Wormy_: деыствительно
18:40.09Wormy_да на самом деле
18:40.41*** join/#sporewiki Hellrock (43b553e0@gateway/web/freenode/ip.67.181.83.224)
18:41.05HellrockHi everyone
18:41.09The_RandomnessHello
18:41.12MonetHi
18:41.25Wormy_hey up
18:41.37TybusenHello
18:55.53TreebeardHello
19:02.40GhelHello.
19:03.14HellrockHai
19:05.33TreebeardHello
19:06.15Tek0516Hello
19:07.48*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
19:09.56ImpyDroidHi
19:10.25GhelHello.
19:11.59MonetHi
19:41.49*** join/#sporewiki ImpyDroid2 (~Anders@62.175.182.135.static.user.ono.com)
20:33.43Wormy_http://imgur.com/gallery/AxzIW1A
20:35.53drom_Wormy_: Yesterday at work, when I was idling after struggling with some paperwork
20:36.33Wormy_You turned purple?
20:36.36drom_While I was that, I googled about artifical gravity, and it hit me that in hard-fiction, there would be no field generator
20:37.10drom_So I read extra about magnetic boots and haranesses
20:38.00Wormy_Okay, completely took that off in the wrong direction there
20:38.17drom_Wormy_: I did not type fast enough
20:38.26TechnobliteratorTybusen, if you're picking it up for the first time, you'll probably be fine with the iOS/Android/PC versions
20:38.36*** join/#sporewiki DrodoEmpire (188e3f51@gateway/web/freenode/ip.24.142.63.81)
20:38.43drom_It turned out I was indeed purple after reading your message.
20:38.52Wormy_lmao
20:38.52TechnobliteratorThey're the easiest to get, have the best OST, and have all the GBA updates, but the graphics are changed a lot, which puts off people who are used to the old versions
20:39.19TechnobliteratorEmulating the SNES version is also really great, but it doesn't have all the content of the updated versions
20:39.41TechnobliteratorEmulating the GBA version also works great if you want extra content and don't mind the OST
20:39.49TechnobliteratorSo, it's up to you :o
20:40.33drom_Anyway, Wormy_. If I had adapted that to my fiction, their ships would have corridors with two floors and lots of ladder props on them, ferromagnetic tiles on them too.
20:40.35TybusenNot sure if I want to sink $16 into my first foray into FF so I might go with the GBA version
20:41.04TybusenI've read though that there are patches that gives the GBA version the SNES music
20:41.20drom_Wormy_: Those floors are being planes facing each other, of course.
20:41.38Wormy_But yes, there's no such thing as a magical gravity generator in physics today: you either use correct amounts of super-dense materials or tiny black holes (mass in a small space), or you use rotation
20:42.21TybusenAlso, GBA is convenient for me if only because I have GBA emulators on both my phone and computer
20:42.38Wormy_Magnetism could secure things, but at a fundamental level it won't help against bone degredation
20:42.54drom_Wormy_: No rotation, adapt micro-gravity suits for the crew and pump lots of medical technology to nullify the atrophy caused by micro-gravity.
20:43.22TybusenTechnobliterator: Do you think the OST changes are a deal breaker for the GBA version? I could get the OST patch for a GBA version but that could be complicated
20:43.54TechnobliteratorIf you can patch the GBA version to update the OST, then that's probably the most ideal option
20:44.09Wormy_Fluid distribution in the body would still also be a problem
20:44.58drom_Wormy_: Reuse the handwavium from the gravity generators to a technology that solves the problem you stated.
20:45.05Wormy_drom_ Actually yeah, one might imagine somekind of bio/nanotech that could fight atrophy
20:45.24Wormy_I get your point
20:45.59Cyrannianhttp://spore.wikia.com/wiki/Vehicle:Nemesis-class_Star_Dreadnought - Started on this
20:46.19drom_Wormy_: Biomechanical augments and other tech-savvy stuff if you are into said technology.
20:47.06drom_For one I've thought of integrated titanium trusses in the bones.
20:47.24drom_It does not solve the problem of the bones shrinking in size however.
20:48.51Tek0516Make the bodily fluids magnetic then use an electromagnetic field to simulate gravity. :P
20:48.54Wormy_Or better yet, have a post-biological spaceforce
20:49.18drom_It may be expensive however, if you have to implement those in every single space-faring individual
20:49.26Wormy_Cyborgs, bots, nanotech, von neumann machines
20:49.45drom_But hell, why would you have awake marines in your transport hold for years and years, doing nothing?
20:49.49Wormy_Possibly not in the far future
20:49.52drom_When you have cryogenic sleepers?
20:50.42Wormy_Or have a cyborg/machines that simply play in virtual worlds till the job is done
20:50.54Wormy_*till the journey
20:51.24drom_Wormy_: There are automation, still
20:52.03drom_Anyway. There is issue number two
20:52.08drom_(and three)
20:52.17drom_Fires
20:52.39drom_They are ludicrously dangerous in micro-gravity environments, since no force keeps them down.
20:53.28drom_To solve this, give the crew fire-resistant suits and have corridors with many airlocks and "firelocks"
20:54.15drom_And assure the electronics and other techno-babble are safe enough to be operated in micro-gravity, regardless condition.
20:54.40drom_Issue three:
20:54.57drom_Growth of micro-scopic life.
20:55.40drom_I read a book about the life as an astronaut, and the challanges they are facing every day, every hour, minute and second.
20:56.03drom_Growth of otherwise harmless bacteria in vents, being one of them.
20:57.11drom_The said bacteria can be found everywhere on Earth, including our homes and food.
20:57.26drom_But in space, they grow in a number large enough to be harmful to humans.
21:02.26drom_To combat that, they clean the vents on a regular basis.
21:02.53drom_Saying this on courtsey of someone that has been on International Space Station
21:03.52drom_Wormy_ Tek0516: http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/10/international-space-station-home-potentially-dangerous-bacteria
21:04.09drom_Since you both showed interest
21:06.47Wormy_Yep to all of that
21:07.48drom_It was a blast to talk about this, Wormy_ Tek0516. Thank you.
21:07.59drom_Now I need to go unconscious
21:08.39Wormy_Goodnight
21:14.32Wormy_http://imgur.com/gallery/eukOsU6
21:27.30*** join/#sporewiki Charles_Murray (53713253@gateway/web/freenode/ip.83.113.50.83)
21:28.24DrodoEmpireHi
21:31.25TechnobliteratorWormy_, will you be able to finish the Reckoning section sometime this week?
21:33.15TechnobliteratorAlso, ImpyDroid2 and Cyrannian, are you guys free to discuss Reckoning sections this week?
21:34.03CyrannianTomorrow perhaps
21:48.13TechnobliteratorTomorrow is good
21:48.28TechnobliteratorI am probably going to write up post-Reckoning fiction early
21:48.43Wormy_Tonight ore tomorrow
21:49.35Technobliterator\o/
22:08.50DrodoEmpire~seen dino82_
22:08.54infobotdino82_ <d8dd47aa@gateway/web/freenode/ip.216.221.71.170> was last seen on IRC in channel #sporewiki, 3d 22h 44m 38s ago, saying: '@drom: Yeah, I liked how it played out, nto the most basic ships as well'.
22:10.28*** join/#sporewiki Hachiman (5aff252c@gateway/web/freenode/ip.90.255.37.44)
22:10.29HachimanHi
22:12.53Technobliteratorhihi
22:15.27DrodoEmpireHi
22:22.19ImpyDroid2hi
22:23.19MonetHi
22:29.59DrodoEmpireSo I'm watching DS9
22:30.33DrodoEmpireAnd I've just been reminded of another glaring flaw in the federation military- civilians on board a warship
22:30.42DrodoEmpire*Even when they know they'll be headed in to battle*
22:30.57DrodoEmpireAll that does is spread panic and make evacuations 10 times harder
22:46.20Wormy_Hachiman:  So there's a black magician on Youtube who does black magic and Satanic magic, and has recently been exploring Lovecraftian evocations
22:46.47Wormy_https://www.youtube.com/user/EAKoettingOfficial
22:46.58HachimanHuh
22:50.15Charles_Murraytest
22:56.48MonetDrodoEMpire: I take it you refer to SIsko losing his wife at WOlf 359?
22:56.57DrodoEmpireYeah
22:57.18DrodoEmpireIt could've *completely avoided* had they used a sensible military doctrine >.<
22:58.15MonetWhat about the Enterprise itself
22:58.29Monet"Charging a Borg Cube? Don't bother evacuatin *any* civvies"
22:58.49MonetThe enterprise has a crew compliment of like 1000
22:58.52DrodoEmpireYeah...
22:58.55MonetNot including spouses and kids
23:03.21MonetI think the idea is the Federation has seen an era of peace for so long they don't see anything dangerous about bringing civilians aboard
23:04.27MonetBut it took them what, 5? 8 years before they launched a vessel not intended to carry families?
23:08.54DrodoEmpireYeah the issue with Starfleet is that since the TOS era its whole doctrine and operation's become watered-down and shitty
23:09.08DrodoEmpireBy TNG it ceased to be an effective military institution
23:11.27*** join/#sporewiki Technobliterator (Technoblit@gateway/shell/firrre/x-pbjgvfjppoglwuak)
23:11.27*** mode/#sporewiki [+o Technobliterator] by ChanServ
23:12.48Wormy_STO is noncanon, but if its anything to go by, the Feds learn the error of their ways
23:13.22MonetOnly took them 30-odd years.
23:14.36DrodoEmpire^
23:14.37DrodoEmpire:p
23:15.07DrodoEmpireIf it took the British or Americans that long to fully militarize, we'd all be speaking German right now
23:16.47Wormy_I think what we must take into account is that the Feds saw themselves as peace keepers, and tbh were the main power of their region.  The average cruiser an front of line ships were more than a match for most neighbouring factions except perhaps the Breen and some Romulan ship classes.
23:17.35Wormy_So they obviously became decadent and had little incentive to be militarised
23:17.37HachimanYeah; they were the main power because there was nobody else in their region to contest them
23:17.42DrodoEmpire^
23:17.54DrodoEmpireWhich is no excuse
23:17.55HachimanNot because of any military or technological advantage
23:18.48DrodoEmpireAfter TOS, the federation wasn't very contested, so their military capabilities rotted away
23:19.16Wormy_Actually they had both really, and their greatest threats (i.e. Cardassians, Romulans and Klingons) were too busy sunk into their own problems and squabbles.  The Federartion's main incentive was to keep them from going to war
23:19.30HachimanI don't see how they had both
23:19.37Wormy_Obviously, it didn't work for the Feds when the Borg and then Dominion showed up
23:20.09HachimanYou had to be ultra shit in order to lose a battle against the Feds
23:20.12Wormy_I didn't read military, woops
23:20.16MonetWhat about the Romaulans?
23:20.30Wormy_They have a general tech advantage over most of their neighbors
23:20.41MonetSingularity cores, clopakign tech, distruptors
23:20.44HachimanI mean, for fuck's sake, the FERENGI outdid the Feds in most areas
23:20.52Wormy_With some exceptions of course - Romulan tech you mention
23:21.06Wormy_Or Breen energy dampening weapons
23:21.14Wormy_Or Tholian energy webs
23:21.32MonetFeds had a quality of life advantage.
23:21.52MonetMaybe some diplomatic skill
23:22.02Wormy_Still we;ve seen Fed ships utterly decimate Roman ships and fleets
23:22.05HachimanAnd humanocentric writing :p
23:22.07Wormy_*romulan
23:22.14Charles_MurrayDepends on what you mean by diplomatic skill
23:22.44DrodoEmpireWormy_: Yeah that doesn't change the fact that they were utterly unsuited to war
23:22.46DrodoEmpireStarfleet was
23:22.57HachimanIf the Federation was in any other science fiction universe, I honestly doubt they'd stand much of a chance against anyone
23:22.57Wormy_I don't disagree
23:23.13DrodoEmpireHachiman: I totally agree
23:23.26DrodoEmpireThey'd be annihilated by most other sci-fi universes
23:23.32Wormy_Their strategy didn't anticipate new threats
23:23.39Charles_MurrayI've been seriously impressed by the ability of the Romulans and Cardassians to navigate power relations, while whenever the Federation did something equally skillful, it was usually overdone by a character who was painted as a villain
23:24.23*** join/#sporewiki Liquid_Ink (79d0cd9d@gateway/web/freenode/ip.121.208.205.157)
23:24.27Wormy_hi
23:24.36DrodoEmpireThat's because real diplomacy and politics are eeeeevil, Charles <.<
23:24.40DrodoEmpireYOU'RE EEEEVIL, CHARLES
23:24.43DrodoEmpire>.>
23:24.48MonetI think Pike was Right in Into Darkness, he was jsut talking about the wrong continuity
23:25.05HachimanThe main thing the Feds have going for them, really, are the writers of the show
23:25.12DrodoEmpireolol
23:25.14DrodoEmpirePretty much
23:25.17MonetPretty-much.
23:25.27*** join/#sporewiki Technobliterator (Technoblit@gateway/shell/firrre/x-qvmrgioxdqnzskoc)
23:25.27*** mode/#sporewiki [+o Technobliterator] by ChanServ
23:25.54DrodoEmpireCharacter shields and movie aimbot are the two most powerful weapons of war
23:26.16DrodoEmpireAnd dumb, miraculous luck is always handy
23:26.53MonetChris Pine's Captain Kirk and his infinite well of dumb luck.
23:27.00DrodoEmpirelol
23:28.01CyrannianIt irks me that in one of the future timelines in STO, both the Klingons and the Romulans have joined the Federation
23:28.25*** join/#sporewiki Charles_Murray (53713253@gateway/web/freenode/ip.83.113.50.83)
23:28.33DrodoEmpireYeah... That sorta eliminates the two biggest plot conflicts, doesn't it?
23:28.44MonetPardon my friech but grande merde how the bloody-hell did they manage that!?
23:28.49MonetFrench*
23:28.58Charles_MurrayWhoops, DCed
23:29.01Wormy_By dogooderising the Klingons
23:29.02Charles_MurrayWhat did I miss?
23:29.10Wormy_fucking dogooders
23:29.33DrodoEmpire[20:25] == mode/#sporewiki [+o Technobliterator] by ChanServ [20:25] <DrodoEmpire> Character shields and movie aimbot are the two most powerful weapons of war [20:26] <DrodoEmpire> And dumb, miraculous luck is always handy [20:26] <Monet> Chris Pine's Captain Kirk and his infinite well of dumb luck. [20:27] <DrodoEmpire> lol [20:28] <@Cyrannian> It irks me that in one of the future timelines in STO, both the Klingons and the Ro
23:29.41MonetThe last time those three worked together the Dominion were the great threat - and even then the alliance had an issue with the Tal'Shiar.
23:29.50CyrannianUgh turns out that the Klingons canonically joined the Feds in the 26th century according to Enterprise
23:30.18DrodoEmpireWormy_: Klingons dindu nuffin
23:31.16MonetWell...Klingons I guess they seem ot vary depending on whose chancellor.
23:31.27Charles_MurrayReal diplomacy has very little to do with speaking softly or being willing to talk, but with the underlying mechanics and systems of the world and the relationships between them. They're not good or bad, they're just there.
23:31.50DrodoEmpire^
23:32.18DrodoEmpireBut the writers think that's EEEEEEEVIL and manipulative <.<
23:33.58Charles_MurrayTest
23:34.22Technobliteratoryou fail
23:34.25TechnobliteratorYOU FAIIIIIIIL
23:34.35Technobliteratornah you're here
23:34.35Technobliteratorhi
23:34.43Charles_MurrayI have brought disonuru on my faimry
23:35.06Charles_MurrayIs a shamefur disrpray
23:35.54DrodoEmpirethatsracist.gif
23:37.03Charles_Murray^
23:37.47Charles_MurraySo I don't know, I'm very much used to approaching those systems in a value-neutral way in order to understand and engage with them academically
23:39.07Charles_MurraySo to see value-tinted depictions of politics in media is a bit odd
23:39.34MonetIts everywhere though
23:40.12MonetI find House of Cards is one of the few more true-to-life portrayals but even that has its exaggerations
23:42.59Charles_MurrayNot really o.o
23:43.25MonetNot even what Frank did to Zoe in the subway?
23:43.39Charles_MurrayWat
23:43.46Charles_MurrayNo, I mean that it's not true to life at all
23:44.04Charles_MurrayIt's a value-tinted interpretation of politics, just like Star Trek, though in the other direction
23:44.46MonetHouse of Cards is a lot more machiavellian fro mwhat I understand.
23:45.35Charles_MurrayIt postulates that the successful political man is a machiavellian by definition, and has a very brutal understanding of how these systems (dubbed "power") works
23:46.05Charles_MurrayIt's fantasy, really
23:47.13Charles_MurrayWhile the Machiavellian himself is a caricature, a character which lives in the imagination, in fiction, and in our interpretations of world systems and worldly characters
23:47.57MonetHe does get away with a lot of crap
23:48.22MonetSome stuff just seems like somehow it was in his favour all along.
23:48.26Charles_MurrayPeople of power are usually just people behind it all, and have to create a character around themselves
23:49.52MonetOkay I mis-spoke
23:51.00MonetFrank's power does come off as something of an addiction
23:52.29MonetHe wants power but doesn't have much idea how to exercise that power.
23:54.34Charles_MurrayRight; What I'm saying is that that's a trope, a trope that people use to understand their politicians and other personalities, but it doesn't actually apply to real people; it's too simple, too convenient.
23:54.44Charles_MurraySometimes it's used accusingly, other times admiringly.
23:55.14MonetSO rather than an accurate portrayal, Frank's a stereotype of the greedy bastard
23:55.34MonetHe wants power and control but no idea why, he just does.
23:56.05Charles_MurrayWell, the stereotype of the ambitious, power-hungry machiavellian
23:56.25Charles_MurrayWhich is a stereotype that some use to understand Hillary Clinton IRL, for example
23:59.03MonetIt might be easier to list the politicians that the stereotype isn't applied to.
23:59.07DrodoEmpireWell, no, *she* is clearly a reptilian
23:59.18DrodoEmpire:')
23:59.21Charles_Murraylol

Generated by irclog2html.pl Modified by Tim Riker to work with infobot.